Civil law is the branch of law that resolves disputes between private parties — people, businesses, and insurance companies — usually by awarding money to the person who was harmed. Every personal injury claim is a civil matter. Criminal law, by contrast, is the government prosecuting someone for breaking the law, with punishment like jail or fines as the outcome.
After a crash or injury, people often ask whether the person who hurt them will “get in trouble.” That’s a criminal-law question. Whether you get compensated for your medical bills, lost wages, and pain is a civil-law question — and the two run on completely separate tracks.
Civil vs. Criminal Law: The Key Differences
| Civil Case | Criminal Case | |
| Who brings it | The injured person (plaintiff) | The government (prosecutor) |
| Purpose | Compensate the person harmed | Punish and deter the offender |
| Burden of proof | Preponderance of the evidence | Beyond a reasonable doubt |
| Typical outcome | Money damages | Jail, probation, fines, record |
| Who decides to proceed | You and your attorney | The district attorney |
| Right to a free attorney | No — but contingency fees mean no cost up front | Yes, if you can’t afford one |
The burden-of-proof row is the one that matters most to injury victims. A civil case requires only that your version be more likely than not — a far lower bar than a criminal conviction. Our guide to the burden of proof explains why that makes civil claims winnable even when no crime is charged.
One Event, Two Cases
The same incident frequently produces both. Consider a Pennsylvania drunk-driving crash:
- The criminal case: The Commonwealth charges the driver with DUI. The driver may face license suspension, fines, or jail. The victim is a witness, not a party, and receives nothing from this case directly.
- The civil case: The injured victim files a claim against the driver (and the driver’s insurer) for medical bills, lost income, and pain and suffering. This is where compensation comes from.
The two cases don’t depend on each other. The driver can be convicted and still fight the civil claim; the driver can beat the criminal charge and still lose the civil case. But they can influence each other — a DUI conviction is powerful evidence in the civil claim and, in Pennsylvania, triggers a limited tort exception that restores full pain-and-suffering rights. Our DUI accident guide covers that interaction in detail.
What Kinds of Cases Are Civil?
Civil law is enormous, but for injury victims the relevant category is tort law — civil wrongs that cause harm. That includes:
- Negligence claims: car, truck, and motorcycle accidents; slip and falls; medical malpractice.
- Intentional torts: assault, battery, and other deliberate harm.
- Strict liability claims: such as defective products and, in some situations, dog bites.
- Wrongful death claims: brought by a family when an injury is fatal.
Workers’ compensation is a related but separate civil system with its own rules, which is why a workplace injury can involve both a comp claim and a civil claim against a third party. Our personal injury practice covers the civil side of all of these.
Why This Distinction Matters to Your Claim
Three practical consequences follow from understanding civil law:
- You don’t need a criminal case to recover. Most injury claims involve no criminal charge at all — ordinary carelessness isn’t a crime, but it is a civil wrong.
- Nobody files your civil claim for you. The DA handles the criminal side automatically. The civil claim exists only if you pursue it, within the deadline.
- The money comes from the civil case. Restitution in a criminal case is limited and rare. Compensation for your full losses comes through the civil claim, usually from an insurance policy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Civil law resolves disputes between private parties and compensates the person harmed, usually with money. Criminal law is the government prosecuting someone for breaking the law, with punishment as the outcome. They use different burdens of proof and run as separate cases.
Civil. An injury claim is brought by the injured person against the party at fault to recover compensation. It’s decided under the preponderance-of-the-evidence standard, regardless of whether any criminal charge was filed over the same event.
Yes. A criminal acquittal means the government couldn’t prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. A civil claim needs only a preponderance of the evidence, so the same conduct can fail as a crime and still succeed as a civil case.






