Comparative negligence is the rule for what happens when more than one person is at fault for an injury. Pennsylvania uses a “modified” version: your compensation is reduced by your percentage of fault, and if you are found more than 50% responsible, you recover nothing at all.
Almost no accident is purely one person’s fault, and insurance companies know it. Comparative negligence is the tool they use to shrink your claim — which makes it one of the most important terms for an injured Pennsylvanian to understand.
How the Rule Works
A jury (or, in negotiations, the parties) assigns each person a percentage of fault adding up to 100%. Your recovery is then reduced by your share. Under 42 Pa.C.S. § 7102:
| Your share of fault | What you recover |
| 0% | 100% of your damages |
| 20% | 80% of your damages |
| 50% | 50% of your damages — you can still recover |
| 51% or more | Nothing. The claim is barred. |
That cliff at 51% is why the fight over fault percentages is so intense. The difference between 50% and 51% is the difference between recovering half your damages and recovering zero.
Who Has to Prove You Were at Fault?
The other side does. Comparative negligence is an affirmative defense, which means the defendant carries the burden of proof for your share of fault. An adjuster saying “you were partly to blame” is an argument, not a finding — and an attorney’s job is to make them actually prove it, which they frequently can’t.
How Insurers Use Comparative Negligence Against You
- Recorded statements. An adjuster asks friendly-sounding questions designed to get you to admit speed, distraction, or uncertainty. Those words become fault percentages.
- “Sorry” at the scene. Apologies and offhand remarks get characterized as admissions.
- Gaps in treatment. Delays in seeing a doctor are argued as evidence the injury wasn’t serious or came from something else.
- Seat belt arguments. In Pennsylvania these are off the table: seat belt use is inadmissible in a civil case and can’t be used to assign you fault.
This is why the steps you take after a car accident matter so much — and why you shouldn’t give a recorded statement before speaking with an attorney.
Multiple Defendants: Pennsylvania’s Fair Share Act
When several parties share fault, Pennsylvania’s Fair Share Act (2011) generally makes each defendant responsible only for its own percentage. The exception: a defendant found 60% or more at fault can be held responsible for the full amount, as can defendants in certain cases such as intentional torts and DUI. This matters when one at-fault party is uninsured or underinsured — it determines whether another party can be made to cover the gap.
A Pennsylvania Example
A driver runs a stop sign on a Lancaster County back road and hits a car that was traveling 10 mph over the limit. A jury finds the stop-sign runner 80% at fault and the speeding driver 20%. The speeding driver recovers 80% of their damages. Had the jury found them 51% at fault, they’d recover nothing — which is exactly the outcome the stop-sign runner’s insurer will push for. Our full guide to comparative negligence in car accident claims goes deeper on how these percentages get argued, and our guide to what your car accident case is worth shows how the reduction applies to the final number.
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, as long as you were not more than 50% at fault. Your recovery is reduced by your percentage — 30% at fault means you recover 70% of your damages. At 51% or higher, Pennsylvania’s modified comparative negligence rule bars recovery entirely.
A jury, if the case goes to trial. In the far more common settlement scenario, the percentages are negotiated between your attorney and the insurer based on the evidence. The defendant bears the burden of proving your share, so unsupported claims of fault can be challenged.
No. Shared fault is normal, and most claims involve some argument about it. Even a significant share of fault leaves a substantial recovery, and insurers routinely overstate fault they can’t prove. Have an attorney evaluate it before assuming your claim is worthless.






