Negligence is a failure to use the care that a reasonably careful person would use in the same situation, resulting in harm to someone else. It is the legal basis for nearly every personal injury claim. To prove negligence in Pennsylvania, an injured person must establish four elements: duty, breach, causation, and damages.
Negligence isn’t about bad intentions. The distracted driver, the store that didn’t mop up a spill, the trucking company that skipped maintenance — none of them meant to hurt anyone. They were careless, and the law holds people responsible for the harm their carelessness causes.
The Four Elements of Negligence
Every negligence claim must prove all four. Miss one, and the claim fails — which is exactly where insurance companies focus their attack.
- Duty
The other party owed you a legal duty of care. Drivers owe everyone on the road a duty to drive safely. Property owners owe visitors a duty to keep the premises reasonably safe. Doctors owe patients a duty to meet the professional standard of care. Duty is rarely disputed in injury cases; it’s usually obvious.
- Breach
The other party failed to meet that duty — they did something a reasonably careful person wouldn’t, or failed to do something a reasonably careful person would. Running a red light, texting while driving, ignoring a known hazard, or failing to secure a load are all breaches. This “reasonable person” standard is the heart of negligence.
- Causation
The breach actually caused your injury. Pennsylvania requires both that the harm wouldn’t have happened without the breach (factual cause) and that the harm was a foreseeable result of it (legal or proximate cause). Causation is where insurers fight hardest, often arguing an injury was pre-existing or came from something else.
- Damages
You suffered real, measurable harm — medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering. A near-miss with no injury isn’t negligence in the legal sense, no matter how careless the other party was. Our guide to what your car accident case is worth explains how damages are valued.
Negligence Per Se: When Breaking a Safety Law Is the Breach
Pennsylvania recognizes negligence per se: when someone violates a safety statute designed to protect people like you, that violation can establish duty and breach automatically. A driver who runs a red light, speeds, or drives drunk has violated a safety law, and the violation itself can prove the first two elements — leaving only causation and damages. It’s why a traffic citation against the at-fault driver matters so much in a car accident claim.
Pennsylvania’s Comparative Negligence Rule
What if you were partly at fault? Pennsylvania uses modified comparative negligence (42 Pa.C.S. § 7102). Your recovery is reduced by your percentage of fault — and if you’re found more than 50% responsible, you recover nothing. Because the defendant bears the burden of proving your share, insurers work hard to inflate it. Our full guide to comparative negligence explains how to push back.
Negligence Across Injury Cases
The four elements stay the same, but what “reasonable care” means changes with the setting:
Truck accidents: Federal rules on hours of service, maintenance, and loading define the duty, and a violation is powerful evidence of breach.
Slip and falls (premises liability): The property owner must have known, or should have known, about the hazard and failed to fix or warn about it.
Medical malpractice: The duty is the professional standard of care, proven through expert testimony — and Pennsylvania requires a Certificate of Merit from a qualified expert at the start of the case.
A Pennsylvania Example
A driver on Route 30 in Lancaster County glances at a text and rear-ends the car ahead, which was stopped in traffic. Duty: every driver owes a duty of safe operation. Breach: looking at a phone instead of the road is not reasonable care — and violates Pennsylvania’s distracted-driving law, supporting negligence per se. Causation: the collision happened because of the distraction. Damages: the front driver’s neck injury, ER visit, and two weeks off work. All four elements are met.
Frequently Asked Questions
Duty, breach, causation, and damages. The other party must have owed you a duty of care, failed to meet it, actually caused your injury through that failure, and the injury must have resulted in real harm. All four must be proven for a negligence claim to succeed.
Negligence established by the violation of a safety law. When someone breaks a statute meant to protect people like you — running a red light, driving drunk — the violation itself can prove duty and breach, so only causation and damages remain to be shown.
Yes, as long as you were not more than 50% at fault. Under Pennsylvania’s modified comparative negligence rule, your recovery is reduced by your percentage of fault. At 51% or more, you’re barred from recovering. The defendant must prove your share of fault.






